|
|
|
Distinctions between Story Types in Literature
From "Anatomy of Criticism"
Deb Lawrence
These are some distinctions Northrop Frye makes in Anatomy of Criticism
about types and dimensions of literature.
1. Dimensions of literature (Frye recalling Aristotle), which have varying
emphasis in different literary forms and also in different instances of a
given form.
- mythos, i.e. plot, which Aristotle calls the ‘soul’ of the story.
- ethos, i.e., characters and setting
- dianoia, or ‘thought’; the ‘point’, or the theme
2, Frye also cites four ‘ethical’ elements of all literature (ethical in the
sense of relating to character):
- hero
- hero’s society
- poet
- poet’s society
3. Frye draws a basic distinction between literature focused on plot and
characters and literature where ‘the point’ is more the focus.
- ‘Fictional’ literature -- emphasis on mythos and ethos. The ‘point’ remains
implicit and is less salient than the story itself. The poet’s relationship to
the society is also not explicit.
Frye’s literary example: Shakespeare
A business example: “What happened this week” stories shared between peer
colleagues.
The basic distinction within literature with a 'fictional' emphasis is, of course, comedy vs. tragedy.
- Comedy -- integration of hero with his society (from which he was previously
excluded for some reason).
Frye's literary example: George Bernard Shaw
Business example: A story about gaining the trust and respect of a client.
-
Tragedy -- isolation of hero from society
Frye's literary example: Thomas Hardy
Business example: The experience of one division within a large firm.
- ‘Thematic’ literature -- emphasis on the dianoia, or ‘the point’. The relation
of poet to reader is more explicit. More didactic. Allegories and fables
have a thematic emphasis.
Frye’s literary example: Pilgrim’s Progress
Business examples: People telling particular stories and drawing explicit
conclusions related to making business decisions. Stories
about ‘how we won client x’, told as instructive.
The basic distinction Frye draws within literature with a ‘thematic’
emphasis has to do with the writer’s relationship to the society.
- Lyric. Poet as individual. Emphasis on poet’s separateness from society and
the distinctiveness of the poet’s vision, the separateness of their
personality. Common in lyrics, essays, and in moods of protest, ridicule or
loneliness. The works tend to be self-contained episodes as opposed to
larger epic cycles.
Frye’s literary examples: Rousseau, Byron, Joyce
Business examples: The relationship of one employee to his/her group or to
technology.
- Epic. Poet as spokesman of society. Articulates knowledge that is already
latent on the society or knowledge that is needed by it. Educational in a
broad sense. The poet of epic works tend to have this type of voice. Poet
as professional with a societal function vis a vis the reader.
Frye’s literary example: Faust
Business examples: Stores told to illustrate what a technology is about
-- Usually stories another employee can re-use to illustrate
the technology to prospective clients and others.
|