Game 2, black
35...Bxd6
Commentary for black move 35:
MAURICE ASHLEY: The jacket is still on. That's a good sign,
that's a good sign. He hasn't taken the jacket off. The
jacket off usually means I'm busted and I've got to find my way
out of this situation.
MIKE VALVO: He's kind of praying now.
PATRICK WOLFF: I don't think he's praying so much as
contemplating, actually. In thought.
MAURICE ASHLEY: I've got to take a different view here, guys.
Garry Kasparov, as we said, shows a lot of emotion. This
particular posture is not one I've seen when he's in trouble.
And I think that he's figured out something -- I don't know
what it is, but something that says you might win a pawn, but
maybe we can take this plan to some kind of interesting endgame
where you're not winning the game. And --
PATRICK WOLFF: Well, let's take a look --
MAURICE ASHLEY: He's not acting right now like a big man. I
heard a fan say, "Come on, Garry, in the audience."
Coming back on stage is Grandmaster
YASSER Seirawan. Mike
Valvo
will go on a break.
PATRICK WOLFF:
YASSER, what do you think about Qb6. Have you
been analyzing this with Lubosh?
MAURICE ASHLEY: Two I will lustryous Grandmasters on stage
with
me, five U.S. championship between them, so they should be able
to answer the question definitely. (Audience laughter.)
PATRICK WOLFF: Five U.S. championships between us, how
come
neither you or I are U.S. champion this year?
YASSER SEIRAWAN: I don't think either of us played. We needed
to give the others a chance.
PATRICK WOLFF: I was worried you would show up.
YASSER SEIRAWAN: We think that -- I'm not using the royal "we"
but Lubosh Kavalek and I, but Garry is in trouble, but he's got
this very intriguing double-pawn sacrifice to try to create a
mating attack. I know that sounds kind of weird. Let's take a
look at it.
PATRICK WOLFF:
YASSER SEIRAWAN: What we were looking at was the move
Rc8-d8,
supporting the bishop, then anticipating a4xb5 --
MAURICE ASHLEY: Kasparov has left the board.
PATRICK WOLFF: Hang on. Before we play that move I should
point
out that white could play the move Be4 here which might stop
juror idea, so let's keep that in mind.
MAURICE ASHLEY: Let's first get the idea so we know where you
guys are headed.
YASSER SEIRAWAN: Okay. a4xb5, and now comes the move
Ra8-b8,
getting off the a-file. Qb6xa6. So that's the double-pawn
sacrifice, and now just the move that Patrick wanted to shut
down, that guy, e5-e4. And we'll see what Fritz thinks now.
MAURICE ASHLEY: So the main idea here is --
AUDIENCE MEMBER: Fritz likes.
YASSER SEIRAWAN: Fritz likes, uh-huh. The main idea is to
create a battery on the h2 diagonal with the move Qe8-e5, and
then trying to come in with Qe5-h2.
MAURICE ASHLEY: Now, Fritz is ignoring that threat as if to say
it's meaningless and advancing the pawn to b6.
PATRICK WOLFF: I'd like to point something out here. The
strategy that
YASSER is suggesting is a very typical strategy
in these type of positions, giving up material for a mating
attack.
Human beings. Even
YASSER who has a profound respect tore
material --
YASSER SEIRAWAN: Absolutely of.
PATRICK WOLFF: -- all human Grandmasters have learned from
experience that this type of counter play is dangerous, we try
to minimize it, we try to avoid these possibilities for the
opponent if we see the opponent is going for it, but it is
precisely this kind of thing that Garry tried to do against
Deep Blue in the first game of the last match, and Deep Blue
took the pawns, said, "Thank you very much," weathered the
attack, and won the game. So this is exactly the sort of thing
that a human might say, "No, no, no, can't allow this kind of
play." But Deep Blue might just calculate it all the way to
the end. We may be in for a very exciting game if something
like this happens.
MAURICE ASHLEY: And probably something necessary to happen,
because Kasparov is not the kind of person who likes to hunker
down and just defend. And maybe it's not good enough in this
kind of position where all the positional trumps are on Deep
Blue's side -- the rooks, the queen penetrating into the
position, the attack on b5, the light squares. There's a lot
going on here, and no doubt Kasparov has seen variations just
like this one and is ready to execute them.
So it will get wild and woolly, and hold onto your hats, because
this is going to go down to the wire.
PATRICK WOLFF: We'll take questions in just a moment. I just
want to point out two things.
First, I want to show you that this move, Qe5 is the idea that
YASSER was angling for, although white has a couple of extra
pawns this, queen check would be very dangerous. One sample
variation goes Qxc4 Qh2+ king let's say f1, and now suddenly
e3. Now also all sorts of dangerous threats are happening
around white's king.
The second thing I would like to point out is that we can go all
the way back to this moment. Remember we were suggesting
white
plays Qb6 and then Rd8. I do want to point out that a human
who saw this position --
MAURICE ASHLEY: It has instead played axb5.
PATRICK WOLFF: My point was going to be white could block the
play by playing Be4, but this is all moot because white has not
played Qb6.
MAURICE ASHLEY: Well, the big question for us is why Qb6 was
not
played, and maybe some of the variations that you just
mentioned,
YASSER, prevent the computer from going into that
aggressive mating idea. Maybe it saw deep enough into the
position to say "Well, we don't to want give him any of those
kind of mating attacks because it will compensate. Instead it
has taken on b5 which comes as a surprise to us. More of a
surprise to me is the fact that it took so long to finally take
on b5 after taking so long on the previous prove.
Kasparov has recaptured with his pawn.
YASSER SEIRAWAN: But actually while I was getting remiked up,
I'm thinking that the move axb5 is actually a very nice move.
It does clarify the position, and let's take a look what Fritz
thinks now of the move Qb6.
MAURICE ASHLEY: Fritz is not as impressed by this move. Fritz
thinks that after Qb6 the position is just slightly
advantageous to white.
PATRICK WOLFF: Yes, but I disagree with Fritz. What Fritz is
saying is Qb6 --
MAURICE ASHLEY: It's actually changed its evaluation as we just
spoke.
PATRICK WOLFF: Good. It should.
MAURICE ASHLEY: It now thinks that wheat has even more of an
advantage with Qb6.
YASSER SEIRAWAN: After an exchange of rooks on a2.
PATRICK WOLFF: This is what it was suggesting. In this position
Fritz saw Qe6+ but I'm sure
YASSER may agree that move may be
prematch, a move like Qb7.
YASSER SEIRAWAN: Keeping all the positional trunks.
MAURICE ASHLEY: And Fritz is agreeing with that evaluation by
giving more of a plus to white.
Real-time text commentary is made possible by LiveNote, Inc.
and Vincent Varallo
Associates