Game 2, black
26...Nf6
Commentary for black move 26:
YASSER SEIRAWAN: Well, let's take a look at what Garry has
done. He's played the move Nh7-f6. So he's inviting Deep Blue
to trade pawns in the center with f4xe5, d6xe5. As a result of
this exchange the f-file has opened up and it's conceivable
that Garry would try to bring a knight to the d6 square or
certainly put a bishop on the d6 square. So Deep Blue isn't
going to see a lot of advantage from trading the pawns, but you
know Deep Blue as well as anybody. Would you expect that Deep
Blue would try to play, for example, the move f4-f5, gaining
more space on the kings side, or do you think he will keep the
tension?
JOEL BENJAMIN: Well, I can never be sure what it's going to do.
There is some argument to take on e5. But since the rooks are
already operating well on the a-file, I don't think that it
would go for a plan of switching the rooks back to the f-file,
so that opening the file wouldn't get much benefit for it. And
it does understand things about block aids, so I think there's
a decent chance that it might push f5, because it introduces
stuff that it knows about as well.
YASSER SEIRAWAN: More space and so on?
JOEL BENJAMIN: Yeah.
YASSER SEIRAWAN: I'm going to take a question from the
audience
soon. I just have one comment. Garry has now won three games
running. Games five and six from Philadelphia, and yesterday's
game. The gentleman in the audience earlier had said, have you
made some changes as of game one, and I know you don't want
to
do that because like you said it could affect other things in
the program. But three games running gives you pause for
thought. Are you on the wrong track, or does the team -- are
they having a rethink at the moment? What's going on?
JOEL BENJAMIN: Well, first of all, you can separate out the
first two games from the sequence because it was already
completely --
YASSER SEIRAWAN: Ancient history?
JOEL BENJAMIN: -- a different program, situation. So really,
Deeper Blue has lost one game running to Kasparov --
YASSER SEIRAWAN: Deeper Blue.
JOEL BENJAMIN: And while there are some changes that can
always
be made, I don't think there's any reason to panic just yet.
YASSER SEIRAWAN: In the audience, the gentleman in the green.
Yes.
AUDIENCE MEMBER: Well, after f4 I was looking at maybe Qf2 and
Bb6 since the bishop on f8 is kind of weak, to activate that
diagonal?
YASSER SEIRAWAN: The gentleman was suggesting that white
may
play the move Qf2 with the idea that he could introduce his
bishop with bishop b6. And I agree with you. The move Qf2 is
a very flexible option, not bad at all. Not bad at all. Good
suggestion.
JOEL BENJAMIN: Yeah, it's certainly possible. We've only talked
about so far that white could take on e5 or push on f5 but the
other possibility is that it will keep the tension and could
very well do that.
YASSER SEIRAWAN: Maybe this is confidential, but prior to the
match a lot of people were making their own predictions. I
thought that Garry still held a significant edge. We do have a
move, by the way, f4xe5. Deep Blue has resolved the tension.
We expect that Garry will quickly recapture with the move
d6xe5. Which he has now done.
What was your prediction -- what was your feeling before the
match? How did you expect Deep Blue would do in the match?
JOEL BENJAMIN: I expected it to be a very close match. I
thought that the final score would probably be 3 1/2-2 1/2 in
somebody's favor. And I thought that probably Kasparov should
be rated a slight favorite, but that he would actually be
considered by most people to be a heavy favorite. But
basically outside of me and a few other people, nobody really
knows going in how good Deep Blue is. So any kind of
predictions are absolute guesswork.
YASSER SEIRAWAN: And what would be, in your opinion, the
pivotal
points? Would it be the choice of openings that would make all
the difference? Would it be tactical? Or how did you imagine
a victory occurring for Deep Blue?
JOEL BENJAMIN: I think probably the most critical question is
getting into the right types of positions. Because when Deep
Blue gets into a position where it has a lot of activity, and
it's difficult to find moves for the opponent, then it can be
devastating. There's no question that there are some positions
that Deep Blue plays better than Kasparov. If it gets to them,
it will win the game. On the other hand, if Kasparov gets to
the positions where -- that he plays much better than Deep
Blue, then he will win.
Real-time text commentary is made possible by LiveNote, Inc.
and Vincent Varallo
Associates